Trang chủInternational FootballPSGC Ciamis and Persikotas Join Forces: Stadion Galuh Becomes a Liga 3 Home Base and the Risks Left Unaddressed
International Football

PSGC Ciamis and Persikotas Join Forces: Stadion Galuh Becomes a Liga 3 Home Base and the Risks Left Unaddressed

PSGC Ciamis và Persikotas Kota Tasikmalaya công bố hợp tác cho mùa Liga 3 2026/2027: Persikotas dùng Stadion Galuh làm sân nhà, kèm giao hữu, giải tiền mùa giải và tuyên bố hòa bình giữa hai nhóm cổ động viên. Key facts: - Thỏa thuận do CEO Herdiat Sunarya (PSGC) và CEO Ecep Suwardaniyasa (Persikotas) trực tiếp thúc đẩy. - Stadion Galuh được đánh giá đủ tiêu chuẩn tổ chức Liga 2 và Liga 3. - Hai nhóm cổ động viên Laskar Singacala và Laskar Wiradadaha được đưa vào chiến dịch thể thao và tuyên bố hòa bình. - Chưa công bố chi phí, hợp đồng, thời hạn hay phương án an ninh. Nguồn: VIVA (thông báo kế hoạch mùa 2026/2027). Q: Vì sao Persikotas chọn Stadion Galuh? A: Vì sân này đạt tiêu chuẩn Liga 2/3, giúp Persikotas tránh chi phí xây dựng hoặc thuê sân đạt chuẩn riêng. Q: Rủi ro lớn nhất là gì? A: An toàn đám đông giữa hai nhóm cổ động viên khi hai đội chung sân, đặc biệt sau thảm họa Kanjuruhan 2022. Q: Thỏa thuận đã chính thức chưa? A: Chưa rõ; hiện mới là tuyên bố hợp tác, chưa có thỏa thuận cấp phép hoặc chi phí được công bố.

Two seasons. That is the time between a promise and reality. PSGC Ciamis and Persikotas Kota Tasikmalaya have announced a cooperation plan for the 2026/2027 season, under which Persikotas will use Stadion Galuh in Ciamis as their home base in Liga 3. In Southeast Asian football, two clubs sharing one stadium is not unprecedented. But the way this announcement was packaged makes it a far more interesting case than an ordinary administrative bulletin. Accompanying the ground-sharing deal is a peace declaration aimed at two supporter groups. No club voluntarily organises a peace declaration for supporters who have never clashed. The very existence of such a measure says more than any revenue figure or league table. Numbers do not lie, but they know how to keep secrets. This article does not mock a cooperation effort at the bottom of Indonesian football. Instead, it tries to read the announcement as a case study for shared stadiums, crowd safety, licensing, and governance at the regional club level. Underneath the glossy veneer of a regional-solidarity story, there are many details that remain untouched. When an agreement is important enough for two chief executives to champion personally, yet entirely lacks numbers, clauses, and oversight mechanisms, it is not a complete plan. It is a memorandum of intent. Liga 3 is the third tier of Indonesian football, below Liga 1 and Liga 2. It is organised through provincial zones before reaching a national round. Operating standards at this level are largely semi-professional or amateur. PSGC Ciamis come from Ciamis Regency, while Persikotas come from Tasikmalaya City, two neighbouring jurisdictions in the Priangan Timur cultural region of West Java. They are close enough to make a ground-share feasible. Both clubs also likely compete in the same West Java qualification zone. That means they could face each other directly during the season at the very stadium both use as home. This is an uncommon situation, and it is not mentioned anywhere in the announcement. Since the Kanjuruhan disaster of October 2026, Indonesia has become a particularly sensitive environment for stadium safety. The tragedy in Malang, which killed more than 135 people, forced PSSI to tighten match-organisation regulations, supporter segregation, and security coordination. Any plan to share a stadium between two clubs with distinct supporter groups must be examined in that light. A peace declaration on paper cannot replace a security protocol with a budget. It also cannot answer who pays for security forces, who is responsible when trouble occurs, and how the two supporter groups will be positioned inside a single venue. The announcement contains three clusters of information. The first is infrastructure. Stadion Galuh is described as meeting the hosting standard for Liga 2 and Liga 3 matches. That is a facility-standard statement, not a sporting-performance statement. The second is operational. The two clubs plan to optimise training facilities, organise friendlies, and hold a pre-season tournament. The third is economic. The announcement mentions sport-tourism development in Priangan Timur and highlights benefits for micro, small and medium enterprises and hotels in Ciamis. The most important quote in the entire announcement is from Herdiat Sunarya, CEO of PSGC Ciamis, who said that the clubs do not look at profit and loss, but at the multiplier effect. Economically, this is revealing because it admits that the deal is not designed to generate profit for the clubs. The promised benefit sits in the local economy, not in club balance sheets. That is not wrong in a public-policy sense, but it raises questions about sustainability. If no profit is created at club level, the arrangement depends entirely on external factors: government support, sponsors, and the goodwill of individual leaders. The second notable element is the asymmetry in sourcing. All quoted material comes from PSGC Ciamis and specifically from Herdiat Sunarya. The CEO of Persikotas, Ecep Suwardaniyasa, is named as a driving force but never quoted. There is no independent confirmation from Persikotas about the scope, duration, or binding nature of the cooperation. In media analysis, such a source structure suggests a PSGC-led initiative or an agreement still in its memorandum stage. An agreement where only one side speaks is an incomplete agreement. The third notable element is the absence of the technical layer. No coach is mentioned. No sporting director, no players, no concrete youth development pathway, no tactical detail. The announcement operates entirely at management and infrastructure level. That means the deal is governance-complete at the executive level and empty at the technical level. Football is decided on the pitch, but this agreement does not say a word about what will happen on the pitch. Tactically, the original article provides nothing to analyse. There is no formation, no pressing data, no xG, no possession stats. Any analyst claiming to see a tactical trend in this announcement is inventing a story. However, one indirect tactical issue deserves attention: home advantage. When a club registers its home base in another city, even a neighbouring one, home advantage erodes. Persikotas players will no longer perform in front of familiar fans. They will play in a stadium where their direct opponents also feel at home. In football, a home ground is not just the turf. It is familiarity with the space, the support of the stands, the pressure exerted on referees by the crowd. All those elements will be diluted in a shared-ground model. Having followed Japanese football for years, I have seen how clubs handle shared stadiums. At first glance it seems simple, but when matchdays clash, everything becomes complicated. Fixtures must be coordinated. Pitch quality suffers when matches become denser. Operating costs must be split. Disputes do not arise from great matches but from mundane matters such as floodlight maintenance schedules or security shifts. When two clubs from different cities share one ground, the problem is even harder because they must decide who gets priority on dates, who sells tickets in which area, and who is responsible when rival fans meet on the way to the stadium. The crowd-safety question is not a secondary one. It is central. Laskar Singacala is the supporter group of PSGC Ciamis, while Laskar Wiradadaha supports Persikotas. Both are named in the announcement as subjects of a peace declaration. In any country, if two supporter groups are placed into a sportsmanship and peace programme on the very first day of cooperation, that indicates a history of friction or a clear awareness of the risk of violence. People do not organise peace declarations for those who have never clashed. Its presence is evidence of an existing problem. Economically, the multiplier-effect promise should be treated with scepticism. A third-tier stadium in Indonesia, with a sparse fixture list and modest attendance, is unlikely to create a huge boost for local hotels and businesses. That does not mean the benefit is zero. It simply has limits. A few matchdays per season can generate some spending at food stalls, cafes, and transport services. To become a genuine sport-tourism driver, one needs a properly designed tourism product, an operator, and a market analysis. The announcement has none of those. Sport tourism is a beautiful concept on paper, but it needs data to survive. Statistics are only a map. The real road lies between the numbers. The decision to target the 2026/2027 season is also noteworthy. The announcement arrives two seasons before the planned start. From a media perspective, this creates immediate goodwill without requiring immediate delivery. But from a governance perspective, a two-season gap is a major challenge. Indonesian third-tier football can change its format, change its zone allocation, and change licensing criteria. Regulations in place today may not exist when the arrangement begins. Two years is long enough for key individuals to change jobs, for political priorities to shift, and for supporter groups to accumulate new grievances. An agreement without a term, without a budget, and without binding clauses rests on shifting sand. The contrarian point here is what makes this story compelling. The peace declaration, which seems like the most humane aspect of the deal, is actually the most worrying signal. It admits that supporter violence has existed before. Likewise, the phrase building a professional, independent, and sustainable regional football ecosystem may imply a quiet critique of how provincial clubs depend on local budgets and sponsors. Independence is a goal without a financial plan. Sustainability is a goal without a revenue source. Professionalism is a goal without a governance structure. Big promises with small details are easily forgotten. This is not a football agreement. It is a regional policy statement dressed in a football jersey. One detail deserves emphasis: both chief executives are central to the deal, yet no mechanism ensures the agreement will survive if either leaves. This is key-person risk. In football organisations, stability comes from structure, not from individuals. A term-limited memorandum, a joint coordination committee, a clear decision-making process: any of these could save the agreement when an individual departs. None appear in the announcement. The deal is described as a handshake between two men. In modern football, a handshake is not an asset. It is a potential liability. In Vietnam, multiple clubs using one stadium is not rare. Ho Chi Minh City once had two clubs using Thong Nhat Stadium, with operations based on lease contracts with a state-owned manager. The difference is that the stadium belongs to the state, and the clubs are merely tenants. No one faces the question of two supporter groups clashing outside the same gate in a derby. The model that PSGC and Persikotas are pursuing is more complex because Stadion Galuh carries the identity of host club PSGC, while Persikotas are long-term guests. That emotional asymmetry will almost certainly create tensions that a peace declaration cannot easily dissolve. There is also the issue that the Liga 3 format may change. Indonesian football has gone through repeated league restructurings over the past decade. If Persikotas are placed in a different zone or forced to play more away matches, the logic of sharing a venue weakens significantly. This is the kind of regulatory and format risk that is easiest to ignore because it does not make a beautiful headline. But it can kill the agreement before the first match is played. The absence of PSSI from the announcement is also telling. A stadium used as a home venue by two clubs in the same league system almost certainly requires federation approval, and registration must follow club-licensing procedures. Nothing in the announcement suggests that step has been taken. The reader should not treat this cooperation as complete. In an announcement that stretches over several paragraphs, the most important thing can easily be missed: there is not a single player in the story. No player names, no positions, no coach. In a football article, that absence is data. It shows a project being built from the top down, starting in the executive corridor, never touching the grass. Football can be managed from an office, but it is decided on the pitch. A cooperation agreement where no one talks about the players, the coach, or the formation is like a chess game being played on an empty board. Between two clubs, there is always an invisible board moving. It can only be read when the two teams actually step onto the pitch. If I were to rate the risk, I would place this agreement in the medium category. No large sums have been invested, no transfer needs protection, and the downside is contained. But medium risk does not mean no risk. The most serious risk is crowd safety. The peace declaration can be a good tool if it is enforced with a budget, with discipline, and with police coordination. It becomes a meaningless piece of paper without those elements. The first match between PSGC Ciamis and Persikotas at Stadion Galuh will be the decisive test. Until then, the question of whether the peace declaration retains its value or remains just a line on paper will be answered in the stands. The silence of the pitch creates a kind of data that has never had a name. That data will begin to be collected as soon as the first match is scheduled. At first glance, this is only a small cooperation story in Indonesian third-tier football. But it contains most of the problems Southeast Asian football is facing: weak infrastructure, limited resources, governance dependent on individuals, and the unhealed wound of a stadium disaster. A ground-sharing deal can be a smart solution for poor clubs. It can also be a time bomb if operational details are not resolved. The difference between those two scenarios lies in the unpublished numbers: security costs, contract terms, fixture schedules, and liability when something goes wrong. Numbers do not lie, but they know how to keep secrets. In this case, they are keeping many secrets.

PSGC Ciamis and Persikotas Join Forces: Stadion Galuh Becomes a Liga 3 Home Base and the Risks Left Unaddressed

PSGC Ciamis and Persikotas Join Forces: Stadion Galuh Becomes a Liga 3 Home Base and the Risks Left Unaddressed

Cầu thủ liên quan